School
supplies wise investment CONSERVATIVE
columnist George Will recently noted that a person
doesnt have a moral duty to do something thats
impossible. In other words, if theres nothing you
can do about something, you cant be blamed for not
doing it.
He lists genocide in Darfur and the
Sudan as examples. The average American cant do
much about such things, he says, so its not fair to
judge someone who doesnt.
I suppose theres some truth to
that. Our hearts may break over a situation, but
what do you do when a problem is so huge and so far
away?
Of course if thats the case,
Wills logic also applies to our ongoing disaster in
Iraq. If theres one thing the Iraqis are teaching
us, its how hard it is to just walk into a country
and make them do things our way. Even when youre
the most powerful nation in the world.
Oddly enough, Will doesnt really
apply his logic to Iraq. He wants to keep fighting
there and says we should which shows us something
important. Because Will actually wants to change
Iraq, he plainly sees that as more possible than
changing the Sudan. This makes me suspect that what
we really want to do, will seem more doable than
something we dont want to do.
I cant claim to be any better than
anybody else on that point. I admit Ive turned I
dont want to into I cant a few times in my
life. And I dont think Im the only one.
Heres another point. Its mighty
easy to mistake I cant do it all for I cant do
anything. None of us, as individuals, can make the
huge nightmares end.
So, as Will says, we shouldnt be
morally required to.
But I think we can and should
try to do what we can, when we can.
Poverty is one more issue thats so
broad and deep, it seems impossible to even dent,
let alone solve completely. Yet there are ways even
the average person can nibble at the corners.
For example, school kids may just
be starting to think about summer vacation right
now. But over at the Family Self Sufficiency Board,
the Community School Supply Assistance Program
people are already getting ready for next fall.
School supplies arent free for
kids. Teachers regularly send kids home with a list
of necessities that their parents are expected to
supply them with. Pencils, erasers, glue, paper,
etc. We all remember our desk full of such goodies
from our school days.
Kids need these things, and someone
has to pay for them. If that doesnt happen, the
kids without them are marked, right from Day 1.
This doesnt cost a lot by the
standards of most of us. But there are plenty of
families out there who have all they can do just to
pay for rent, heat, and food if they can even pay
for that.
I cant think of a single kid who
asked to be born poor. Yet at this moment, nearly 20
percent (yep, one out of five!) of Indiana children
live in poverty.
That includes a surprising number
of families in Bartholomew County. And its getting
worse, not better.
School supplies dont cost that
much for someone who has the money, but they cost
plenty for someone who doesnt. Kids who cant walk
in the door with these supplies the way their
classmates can are hamstrung right from the word
go. They dont perform as well, that problem builds
each year, and they get farther and farther behind.
A close a look at AYP test scores shows that
performance is solidly linked to family income.
Ten or 12 years on, the child is
out of the school system and looking for a job. But
decent jobs go to people with decent educations, so
the poverty just gets recycled. Recycling is a good
thing for newspapers and soda cans but a bad thing
for people.
Heres the good news: the school
supplies were talking about (and a backpack to put
them in) can be had for about twenty bucks. Last
year, using community and corporate donations, the
Community School Supply Assistance Program provided
filled backpacks for more than 1,000 kids. That gave
each one of those kids a better shot at a decent
future. Every single child who manages to take
advantage of that shot is one more small victory
over poverty.
If, as George Will says, were not
morally required to do the impossible arent we
doubly required to do whats helpful and easy?
Donations can be sent to the Community School Supply
Assistance Program, 1531 13th St., Suite G600.
Columbus, IN 47201.
The Rev. Dennis McCarty is a Unitarian Universalist
minister living in Columbus. His opinions are his
own and not necessarily shared by members of his
church. He can be reached by e-mail at
columnists@therepublic.com